>>2012
Anons don't care for CYOA dumping, if they wanted that, they would go to Reddit or, god forbid, browse the Allsync.
Technically, the archive does exist, it's just hard to navigate, requires manual backing up, and destroys media. Navigation and backup can be handled by the threadslave, but media being lost is a hard sell. Best workaround for media is requiring the original desciptive filename so it's immediately obvious what was posted even if it can't be viewed.
The thread cycle is pivotal to discussion as a new thread make previous discussion cease and allows new topics and CYOA to be viewed. I'd say keep the image limit, but lower the post limit to 500. No thread should last longer than 2 days.
Most of what disgusts /CYOAG/ about /CYOAR/ is niche fetish content and the belief that sexualization degrades the hobby. Otherwise the hate is mostly one way. As such /CYOAR/ should have a containment thread and maybe be broken up between extreme fetish content and mild sexuality but that last part is up to /CYOAR/. No explicit content should be posted outside of their primary and associated threads, with all explicit content spoiler marked.
/MCYOAG/ is going to refuse to participate regardless so no point apealing to them.
While having all of the one CYOA threads is neat, there is zero discussion for vast majority, many of them are lewd and not spoiler marked. I'd say delete them, but if all goes well, they'll get bumped off anyways.
Not being able to post pdfs is quite bad, if it wasn't so, Spirit Conscript could be posted and kickstart discussion. Maybe we can get EntropistAnon to release Conquest here?
Everything should be kept in Three thread until there is enough activity to have multiple discussion threads. First thread is a general CYOA discussion, second thread is a CYOA creation thread seperate from meta, and third is lewd CYOA containment. Anons will do as anons do though so organic threads should not be pruned unless made in obvious bad faith.
The last point of contention for CYOAs is that of exposure, one of the main reasons for staying on halfchan is that there was enough people being brought in to keep popular. This site however is a deterent to anyone who could be intrested and the board is isolated enough from the rest of the site that there is virtually no crossover. With the amount of refugees there should be alot of opportunity to intruduce people to the hobby, but we badly positioned to do so, maybe we can promote board specific CYOAs to apeal to them? If such a scheme can become a staple of chan culture maybe it can occupy a roll similar to Wojacks or greentext and end those worries.
Threads are legitimized by the presence of discussion, not CYOA. For the potential new general, the thread starter should be something like Order vs Chaos, Spirit Conscript, or Entropist. Something that envokes ire and intrest, hell maybe even Tok, as long as he doesn't start schizoing and posting porn.